Progressive vs Dairyland — Which Is Better for You?
Wondering whether Progressive or Dairyland is the right fit? We compare coverage, rates, financial strength, and more to help you decide.
Compare Both Carriers' RatesAt a Glance
Progressive
One of the largest auto insurers in the US with competitive rates and innovative tools.
- ✓Drivers with violations
- ✓Multi-policy bundling
- ✓Usage-based discounts
- ✓Online quote shoppers
Dairyland
Affordable auto and motorcycle insurance since 1953.
- ✓Motorcycle owners
- ✓Non-standard auto
- ✓Budget coverage
- ✓Independent agent access
Key Highlights
Why Choose Progressive
- •Much broader product lineup including home, boat, and RV
- •Available nationwide in all 50 states
- •Digital tools like Snapshot® and Name Your Price®
- •Direct-to-consumer quoting plus agent access
Why Choose Dairyland
- •One of the largest motorcycle insurers in the US
- •Backed by Sentry Insurance Group (A+ AM Best)
- •Specializes in non-standard auto at competitive rates
- •Strong independent agent network nationwide
Which Should You Choose?
Both Progressive and Dairyland are solid choices, but the right one depends on your situation. Progressive is best known for drivers with violations, while Dairyland stands out for motorcycle owners.
In terms of financial strength, Progressive holds an AM Best rating of A+ compared to Dairyland's A+. Progressive offers 6 products while Dairyland offers 2, so Progressive has a broader coverage lineup.
The best way to decide? Compare personalized quotes from both. Rates can vary dramatically based on your specific profile — your driving record, location, age, and coverage needs all affect pricing. Truvo makes it easy to compare quotes from Progressive, Dairyland, and 40+ other carriers in minutes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Progressive or Dairyland cheaper?
Rates vary based on your driving record, location, age, and coverage needs. Progressive and Dairyland use different rating factors, so one may be significantly cheaper for your profile. The best way to find out is to compare personalized quotes from both through Truvo.
Which has better coverage — Progressive or Dairyland?
Progressive offers Auto, Home, Renters, Motorcycle, Boat, RV coverage, while Dairyland offers Auto, Motorcycle. The "better" coverage depends on what you need — consider factors like policy limits, deductible options, and add-on coverages available from each carrier.
Which is better for high-risk drivers — Progressive or Dairyland?
Both carriers serve a range of driver profiles. Progressive is best for drivers with violations and multi-policy bundling, while Dairyland is best for motorcycle owners and non-standard auto. Compare quotes from both to see which offers you the best rate.
How do I choose between Progressive and Dairyland?
Consider your priorities: price, coverage breadth, financial strength, customer service, and state availability. Progressive is rated A+ by AM Best, while Dairyland is rated A+. Truvo compares quotes from both carriers so you can make an informed decision.
See Which Carrier Offers You the Best Rate
Compare personalized quotes from Progressive, Dairyland, and 40+ other carriers — free and in minutes.
Get Your Free Quote