Skip to main content
All Tools

Accident Cost Tool

Beyond the damage — what an at-fault accident does to your premiums for years.

Your Current Situation

$150
$50$500
$3,376
total 3-year cost of this accident

Impact on Your Premium

Premium Increase
44%
Current Monthly
$150
New Monthly
$216
Monthly Increase
Warning: +$66
Extra Cost Per Year
Warning: $792
Estimated Deductible
$1,000

Year by Year

Surcharges typically last 3 years after an at-fault accident

With Accident

Year 1
$2,592
Year 2
$2,592
Year 3
$2,592

Without Accident

Year 1
$1,800
Year 2
$1,800
Year 3
$1,800
3-Year Difference+$2,376

With vs Without Accident Forgiveness

No Forgiveness
$2,376
extra over 3 years
With Forgiveness
$0
extra over 3 years
Accident forgiveness could save you $2,376 over 3 years

Make sure you have the right coverage

Compare policies with accident forgiveness from 40+ carriers.

Get Your Free Quote

Estimates for educational purposes only. Actual rates vary by carrier and individual factors.

How Accidents Affect Your Insurance Rates

An at-fault accident typically raises your premiums by 20–50% for three to five years, depending on your carrier and state. That means a single fender-bender could cost you thousands of dollars in higher premiums on top of any deductible or repair expenses.

Some carriers offer accident forgiveness programs that waive or reduce the surcharge after your first at-fault claim. Others penalize every incident equally. This is why comparing carriers matters — two drivers with the same accident can pay very different rates.

Get quotes from 40+ carriers to find one that treats your driving history fairly