Toyota Insurance Cost — Average Rates by Model

The Toyota Corolla is typically the cheapest to insure at an average of $1,350/yr. Its compact sedan classification, 5/5 NHTSA safety rating, and low theft risk all contribute to lower premiums.

The Toyota Highlander has the highest average insurance cost at $1,850/yr. As a mid-size suv, it has higher repair costs and replacement value, which drives up premiums.

Yes. Toyota vehicles generally earn strong safety ratings, which can qualify you for insurance discounts. Models with IIHS Top Safety Pick+ ratings may see lower premiums compared to vehicles with lower ratings.

Compare quotes from multiple carriers (Truvo compares 40+ for free), choose a model with lower insurance costs, maintain a clean driving record, bundle your auto and home policies, and ask about available discounts like safe driver or anti-theft device discounts.